HIGHLAND FALLS, N.Y. — Tyhier Tyler scored on a 4-yard run early in the fourth quarter, the Army defense stoned Navy with a goal-line stand in the third, and the Black Knights beat their archrival 15-0 on Saturday at fog-shrouded Michie Stadium.
It was the first meeting between the teams at West Point since 1943. The game was moved to Michie Stadium from its customary site in Philadelphia because COVID-19 regulations in Pennsylvania would not have allowed the Corps of Cadets and Brigade of Midshipmen to attend.
The Black Knights (8-2) posted their first shutout in the series since a 27-0 victory in 1969 and have won four of five against Navy (3-7). They had lost all three games played previously at West Point to the Midshipmen, including 13-0 in 1943 during World War II.
Navy still leads the series 61-53-7.
No fans were allowed, so there wasn't much of a home field advantage for the Black Knights. When the game began the Mids and Cadets were seated in groups on different sides and behind both goalposts, and the stadium literally shook after President Donald Trump conducted the coin toss and the Mids won.
Army had three weeks off to prepare after its game Nov. 7 against Air Force was switched to next Saturday because of COVID-19 concerns in and around the Air Force academy. Navy was coming in off four straight losses.
Xavier Arline started for Navy, just the fifth freshman to start at quarterback for the Mids against Army. Tyler, who had played in four games prior to Saturday, made his second straight start.
Army went up 3-0 on Quinn Maretzki’s 37-yard field goal early in the second quarter, set up by Tyler's 28-yard completion to Tyrell Robinson, just the second completion of his career.
Tyler scored after a Navy turnover, the only one of the game, and Daryan McDonald tacked on a safety late in the fourth when he tackled Navy wide receiver Mark Walker in the end zone on a reverse.
Maretzki added a 40-yard field goal.
Arline sparked the Mids right after the second-half kickoff, and that's when the game turned. He gained 11 yards on first down and then ripped off a 52-yarder, crossing the field from right to left. Only a saving tackle by Cedric Cunningham at the 2 prevented a touchdown and it proved crucial.
When two runs netted nothing, Navy coach Ken Niumatalolo called timeout. The Army defense then rose to the occasion, with senior linebacker Jon Rhattigan stopping Arline inches of the goal and linebacker Amadeo West stopping Nelson Smith on fourth down. It was the eighth tackle of the game for West, a career high.
Neither triple option offense got untracked as fog descended low over the field. The teams headed to the locker room at halftime having combined for five first downs and 132 yards on 44 plays.
Navy: The Midshipmen showed promise defensively late in the season and if Arline is the starter at quarterback next year he’ll give them a better running threat. He finished with 109 yards rushing on 17 attempts.
Army: The Black Knights have overcome a schedule that had to be almost totally revamped to rebound after a subpar 2019. Their only losses before Saturday were on the road against unbeaten Cincinnati (24-10) and Tulane (38-12). Army is 7-0 at home.
Navy senior tri-captain Billy Honaker wore No. 68 in honor of former offensive lineman David Forney, who died of cardiac arrest in his dorm room at the Naval Academy in February.
Forney's number was not issued this season, but Honaker received permission from Forney's father and Niumatalolo to pay tribute to his fallen teammate. Navy has honored Forney throughout the season by wearing a sticker on the back of its helmets that pictures him running out of the tunnel at last year's Army-Navy game carrying the American flag with the word Brotherhood underneath.
Marine One was grounded by the weather, so President Donald Trump came by motorcade. He was greeted with cheers and chants of USA! USA! as he made his way onto the field for the national anthem and coin toss and was in the stands for the opening kickoff. He first took his place with cadets on the Army side of the stadium for much of the first quarter before joining Navy midshipmen in the second quarter. He wore a face mask at times while with both groups and was accompanied by acting Defense Secretary Chris Miller before departing just before halftime.
Navy: Every team is bowl eligible this season, but the Midshipmen's season is likely over.
Army: Hosts Air Force next Saturday in the regular-season finale for the Commander-in-Chief's Trophy and is scheduled to play in the Independence Bowl the next week.